SportsFilter: Sports Community Weblog

Friday, February 20, 2004

NBA: All style, no substance- A jeremiad from Oscar Robertson on the shallow state of the NBA. via the Easterblogg

Comments

Team play is no longer considered sexy. Individual showmanship is. But one player, no matter how gifted, does not build and sustain a championship franchise. cobra, great link!

Pretty well written too...attaboy Oscar! Care to tackle hockey next?

Care to tackle hockey next? All substance, no style?

The thing in my mind when I was reading it was "but... but... The Timberwolves play as a team, and their key players all have pretty well-rounded games..." It's tough for me to tell if they're really an exception, or if I'm just blinded by fandom. Sacramento and San Antonio also seem to play as fully-evolved teams, at least to me.

I would've mentioned the same teams as exceptions. And to be fair, the successful playoff teams function as well-oiled units. But its the general perception of the game, i.e. "Mr.Robertson, how do I up my ups?", that is the problem. And this symptom is primarily why alot of people like NCAA hoops more than the brand of ball the NBA sells.

I caught the Sixers-Nuggets game the other night, and it was really ugly. You can chalk some of it up to knocking off the rust from the All-Star break, but I was really amazed at how bad the product actually was. There was very little movement on the offensive end, and the transition D was nonexistent. I don't know why people pay to see these games. I don't think it's any secret that the decline of fundamental skills is closely related to the increase in early entry draftees. Surely there's a GM out there who's read Moneyball, right? That was the first NBA game I'd watched in a long time.....at least since the 02 playoffs. And yeah, I love me some college hoops.

But one player, no matter how gifted, does not build and sustain a championship franchise. I'd have to say mostly right, but if he didn't do it, Jordan came damn close.

pivo: yeah, it's mostly not possible, but it's a lot closer than you can do in any other major sport.

Comments are closed for this entry.