I don't think the NFL should have to do anything about this, if they hadn't already set a precedent.
I agree with this as well and I think it's gong to be difficult to ever go back now. I don't know that it will ever happen at this point. I do know that this case would probably not be the best time to wash your hands of dispensing discipline.
Further, I'm really not a fan of this broader trend in recent years, this PR-driven idea that until the angry twittering hordes have been sated in their lust for vengeance and biblical retribution, you simply must keep punishing private individuals in some publicly visible way.
This bugs me even when I think the person who Twitter's Eye of Sauron is gazing at is deserving of scorn. I'm here for the protest but then it starts turning into a mob, flipping over cars and breaking in windows, and suddenly I'm not so keen on the cause.
There's a clear double standard at work when it comes to male and female violence that I call "incredibly sexist".
I guess I'm fine with the double standard. I don't think it's a product of sexism, I think it's a product of the reality of men being generally bigger and more capable of causing physical damage. If I seeing it become more of a problem going the other way I'll change my view.
posted by tron7 at 01:02 PM on September 11
The Pirates' John Holdzkom has brought the palmball back to Major League Baseball.
I can't figure out why that would do anything other than go deceptively slowly. Also, where is the best place to find more of this pitch-porn? I've seen the PitchCraft stuff over at Grantland and need more.
posted by tron7 at 04:59 PM on September 10
Ooh, are we starting a hivemind?!
posted by tron7 at 04:50 PM on September 10
The NBA is negotiating a new media deal that is reportedly in the $2 billion dollars a year range which would boost the cap by about $16 million for the 2016-17 season.
posted by tron7 at 10:47 AM on September 09
It is baffling to me that these consequences weren't dolled out originally. Who would've complained if this had been the original punishment? A handful of Ravens fans who would've been silenced as soon as the video leaked. Instead, the league and team piss off everyone with uneven punishments that look like they are only protecting their bottoms and bottom lines. So it looks like the League wanting to protect it's stars but then the league is still crushing players for marijuana. I realize there is language in the CBA specifically regarding marijuana but Goodell has shown no qualms about flexing his power before. Who is going to turn away from their fandom because Josh Gordon got his suspension reduced or removed?
The motivations have always seemed very clear when it came to the NFL and Goodell but this year it seems like he just let go of the wheel.
posted by tron7 at 10:36 AM on September 09
Are we doing the NFL pick-em again?
posted by tron7 at 11:11 AM on September 02
It's a cruel condition for anyone but it seems fantastically cruel for someone who spent his career as a communicator. Great job by NFL Films to get the story across for him.
posted by tron7 at 05:00 PM on August 17
Westbrook was a liability at first.
Westbrook wasn't good his rookie year but he was far from a disaster. Anthony Bennett's season was on a different level of suck.
Andrew Bynum comes to mind
It's 300 minutes from an 18 year old but it's still a good example of a player having a horrible rookie season and turning into an all star. It's not quite as bad as Bennett's rookie season but it's close enough.
posted by tron7 at 10:40 AM on August 06
How many good NBA players do you know who started off with a year that bad? I'm struggling to think of any examples at all. Would I completely give up on him? No, but I also wouldn't think twice about trading him for a top ten player.
posted by tron7 at 01:42 AM on August 06
Looks like Kevin Love will be going to Cleveland by way of Philadelphia.
I thought they'd be be a 50 win team before and I think they'll crush the East now. Losing Wiggins hurts them about 3-4 years from now but there's a significant chance that Wiggins never gets as good as Love is right now. The Cavs butchered LeBron's first go around by overpaying for marginal or over the hill talent. This is different, Kevin Love is just entering his prime and is already a top 5-10 player.
So Cleveland trades away it's two #1 picks to land Kevin Love?
Anthony Bennet had such a horrible year that his value is well below what you would normally see for a #1 pick. I mean, it was nearly Adam Morrison bad.
posted by tron7 at 04:46 PM on August 05
...Jason Whitlock who told us we couldn't judge Ray Rice because we didn't know what happened and the fact the DA is letting him off suggests there must be extenuating circumstances because DAs aren't in the habit of cutting young black men a break.
I haven't really been following this story. Do we know why the DA is letting him off? I think that bugs me more than the length of the NFL suspension.
Of all the suspensions Goodell has handed out I can't believe this is the one he chooses not to be heavy-handed on. He had to know the league was going to come under scrutiny for a small suspension.
posted by tron7 at 05:38 PM on July 25
This is probably the most baffling use of unwritten rules I've ever seen. Usually there's something you could point to that, if you were feeling really touchy, you could construe as being disrespectful somehow. This one though, there's just nothing there.
I'm starting to think baseball needs unwritten rules just to have something to get worked up about. Baseball doesn't have the physical interaction with the opposing team that the other team sports have so there's less tangible things to get upset about. If you really want to hate another team, out of frustration most likely, and you don't have any hit batters or hard slides, you have to search and grasp for reasons why. Unwritten rules are conveniently not written down so you can always find one obscure enough that someone on the other team is bound to offend it out of ignorance.
posted by tron7 at 03:11 PM on July 21
When Kramer was a late addition for Khedira I was sure it was a day he would never forget.
posted by tron7 at 10:52 AM on July 15
So the win essentially came down to my dislike for Tiki-taka and my 50% Dutch blood.
posted by tron7 at 10:45 AM on July 15
As for maximizing his money, why is LeBron the only guy who signed this sort of deal?
Because it's riskier. There's no one else who has signed recently that would be a sure fire max guy in two years. If Bosh and Melo can get 100 million it's safer to just do it now because they are less likely than LeBron to be worth substantially more in two years.
posted by tron7 at 12:49 PM on July 13
Leaving aside Gilbert, what did the fanbase do other than express anger and disappointment?
Other than the jersey burning, I saw the same sentiments that Gilbert outlined in his letter coming out of the mouths and keyboards of every Cavs fan I interacted with. The circumstances explain why the city reacted as it did but I don't think it excuses them.
posted by tron7 at 03:08 PM on July 11
Woah. It did not look like it was going to stop. That would have been amazing.
posted by tron7 at 02:12 PM on July 11
Maybe that was Cleveland's 4 years in the wilderness before they were taken to the promised land?
posted by tron7 at 02:05 PM on July 11
Ahh, I think you're onto something here, it was retroactive karma.
I would be happy for them if the fanbase and Gilbert hadn't reacted so childishly to LeBron leaving in 2010. I can't think of anything a NBA fanbase has done that is more distasteful to me. To see them get LeBron back, on top of the first overall picks the lottery has been cramming down their throat, rubs my sense of justice the wrong way.
posted by tron7 at 01:56 PM on July 11
The letter from Dan Gilbert, the booing of the Cleveland fans, the jerseys being burned -- seeing all that was hard for them.
Does any city deserve this less than Cleveland? Everybody makes mistakes, sure, but usually you have to pay for them.
posted by tron7 at 12:59 PM on July 11
Bear in mind this is also the new Milwaukee ownership group that may have paid up to $150M more than needed to acquire arguably the league's weakest franchise.
Or $100M less than the highest offer. Yeah, it seems high but every franchise being sold right now is going for way over the expected price.
I wouldn't say he was "smelling like a rose"
Well Buck's ownership would. I appreciate that Lasry and Edens wanted to make a splash but I can't believe they went with this particular cannonball.
posted by tron7 at 10:07 PM on June 30
The Bucks saw how he turned around the mess in Brooklyn...
That's one way to look at it. You could also say he was a big part of the mess at the beginning of the season. When the dust settled he had a team that finished 8 games under their preseason over/under and wasn't a serious playoff contender. There was bad and good. I don't see how he gets out of the season smelling like a rose when he looked like a bumbling idiot for the first couple months of the season.
posted by tron7 at 12:40 PM on June 30
Why is Jason Kidd a sought-after coaching prospect? Wait, I'll rephrase. Is Kidd using witchcraft or sorcery in order to convince owners to hire him? The Bucks gave up two second rounders for Kidd and there was some talk of giving him full control, even if it's just the coaching position for now. I have no idea how Kidd commands this level of respect.
posted by tron7 at 11:42 AM on June 30
I'm really amused by Suarez's insistence on biting dudes.
posted by tron7 at 02:14 PM on June 24
I want him to go back to Cleveland...
There is nothing I want less. Cleveland is probably the only team he could go to where I would actively root against him.
posted by tron7 at 01:09 PM on June 24
If he wants to win a championship in Miami he needs to opt out and resign at a lower salary so the Heat can buy a better supporting cast.
It would help but it's not a requirement. Hell, even at max money he's wildly underpaid. If you can't put a contender around LeBron, it's not LeBron's fault.
Miami as constructed is just fine, by the way. They could transition away from their frenetic trapping, and physically demanding, defense that's been producing diminishing results and continue to rule the East with their current roster plus a few minor tweaks.
posted by tron7 at 01:07 PM on June 24
Something is definitely wrong with the scoring, it says I'm winning?!
posted by tron7 at 05:20 PM on June 20
For reference, here's Alex Avila getting hit on Friday by David Ortiz's follow through. See the difference in Papi's reaction?
It proves that Machado doesn't care but not necessarily that he did it on purpose. If it was intentional, it looks a lot more natural than his bat throws do.
posted by tron7 at 12:00 AM on June 09
Machado overreacted to being tagged in the chest forcefully (while attempting to dodge the tag)
I'll say. That's pretty touchy if that's what started the whole thing. Why they decided to retaliate the next day, after they'd presumably seen a replay, is a little perplexing. I guess once you start jawing you don't want to back down even when there's video evidence showing a rather benign play.
What would have happened if he had actually hit the pitcher with the bat?
posted by tron7 at 11:55 PM on June 08
Argh... linked before I completely read. Not Win Shares but is using Win Shares.
posted by tron7 at 01:06 PM on June 04
Gasol doesn't get enough credit for his stretch from '08 - '11. His rank in Win Shares over that stretch: 4th in '08-09, 7th in '09-10 (65 games), 2nd in '10-11. He played with Kobe so he gets overlooked but his numbers definitely warranted some MVP attention.
There's also his Spanish National team accomplishments as the basketball hall of fame is not limited to NBA performance.
Even so I'm not sure if he's hall of fame or not. I really don't have a good handle for exactly how good you have to be for basketball hall of fame consideration.
On edit: Here is an ESPN the magazine article suggesting a re-do of the hall with an arbitrary Win Shares cutoff of 100 and Gasol is at 113.1
There's a giant ad blocking my link button
posted by tron7 at 12:48 PM on June 04
big money, high profile, racist vanquishing owner in town looking to prove himself with the Clippers.
I know he says he plans on keeping the team in Los Angeles but it was just a year ago he was trying to move the Kings to Seattle. I'm not sure whether it's better to split the LA market or own the Seattle market or how much that even matters to Ballmer.
posted by tron7 at 10:20 AM on May 30
I had heard some rumblings that this might happen. I'm not sure it effects the USMNT's chances all that much but it really makes me sad.
posted by tron7 at 10:54 AM on May 23
And Kawhi Leonard, the quietest superstar, leads the team in Win Shares.
posted by tron7 at 10:50 AM on May 23
This is probably #2 on the top 5 list of reasons why soccer/football isn't bigger in North America.
It's the #1 thing that's mocked but I don't think it's that big of a reason why North Americans aren't into soccer. The NBA has plenty of flopping and they're doing all right.
posted by tron7 at 02:35 PM on April 15
Ahhh tron7, it appears you need a calibration on your sarcasm detector.
Is there a version of Poe's Law that applies to umpire satire? It's either that or I'm still smarting from the bat being taken out of my hands on my first at bat of the summer.
posted by tron7 at 05:49 PM on April 04
Umpires do not make the wrong call! They might make the incorrect call at certain times, but because the umpire makes the call, and it is a judgement call, the call is not wrong. If replay is used, and the call is overruled, the umpire was not wrong, merely incorrect.
I call therefore it's right. Might help you sleep at night but it's infuriating to players having to deal with the "right" albeit incorrect calls.
posted by tron7 at 12:50 PM on April 04
The Rays cut 3,000 seats at the Trop, mostly to make a walkway that circles the field.
Meanwhile the Rockies cut a bunch of seats (I can't seem to find how many) to put in a rooftop bar (AKA the Party Deck or Poop Deck depending on who you're talking to). There's been some criticism regarding the Monfort's spending priorities and focus on booze, there's already a microbrewery in the stadium. Personally, I think it looks great but I assume it's going to be hell getting in there for awhile. I'd really like it if they opened her up when the Rockies are out of town. Having a beer overlooking the empty stadium just after the sun drops over the mountains and sets their rims aglow... well, that sounds mighty nice.
posted by tron7 at 09:19 PM on April 01
Heard about the play but I hadn't seen it until now. Wow, that is terrifying.
posted by tron7 at 08:02 PM on March 22
Decker was telling one of the local guys here that the Jet's offer was far and away the most money he was being offered. The other offers being in the 5 million per year range. The Broncos didn't even make an offer according to him.
posted by tron7 at 11:11 AM on March 14
Show me an NBA game from the last decade better than George Mason getting to the Final Four.
Game 6, 2013 NBA Finals
Though, I don't watch college sports very often anymore so one seems infinitely more important than the other through my eyes.
posted by tron7 at 01:13 PM on March 04
How many DPOY awards is it going to take to tuck that girlfriend story under the fold? I still can barely believe that story was real.
posted by tron7 at 02:18 PM on February 11
Michael Lombardi out as Browns GM.
posted by tron7 at 12:14 PM on February 11
Super Bowl summary in one animated .gif:
Source of this is Breaking Madden (not sure if it was posted here). Pretty amusing read and a decent depiction of what it felt like watching the Super Bowl as a Bronco fan.
posted by tron7 at 02:33 PM on February 03
The most striking thing to me about Seattle's defense is how extraordinary their tackling is. If they touch you, you're on the ground. No extra yards. Very rarely do you even see the pile get pushed. I've been watching Demaryius all year and haven't seen him bottled up and dropped so easily. Knowshon was running into piles exiting via the same door he used to get in. I didn't realize how big of an impact that would have on Denver's offense.
I can't think of any Bronco that had a good game. That seems strange to me. I would think at least someone somewhere would have played well but it seems that every individual was bested by their counterpart.
posted by tron7 at 02:15 PM on February 03
His career was cut down in it's jersey-selling prime! He was on pace to be a first-ballot entry into the jersey-selling hall of fame.
posted by tron7 at 04:50 PM on February 02
I've said it before and I'll say it again: No one in the NFL is paid to play football. They are paid to sell tickets and jerseys to fans and eyeballs to advertisers.
Then how do you explain Tebow not having a job?
posted by tron7 at 12:56 PM on January 31
I seriously doubt any player can consider themselves great at the cornerback position without having an attitude that will, obviously, turn some people off.
He'll share the field with one this Sunday.
posted by tron7 at 05:23 PM on January 28
As I read the rule, a punter or kicker in the act of attempting a tackle wouldn't be likely to get hit in a way that draws a penalty.
Any time a punter/kicker gets hit they are either tackling someone or trying to get into position to tackle someone. If a kicker gets hit completely away from the play then you have my full blessing to flag and fine.
I've never heard of punters or kickers practicing blocking or tackling.
Maybe they should. Maybe not tackling but find a way to increase their awareness as the hits that usually hurt kickers and punters are the blindside variety.
posted by tron7 at 04:54 PM on January 14
Was that the goal?
posted by tron7 at 04:47 PM on January 14
he will literally get his fucking neck broken out there.
That guy was trying to block and/or tackle. That's his job too. Would that hit draw a fine if it was put onto another special teamer? I'm not really sure if it would or not. The way the NFL is going right now, for better or worse, is that if you hit anyone hard you're likely to draw a penalty or fine.
posted by tron7 at 04:13 PM on January 14
I don't think there's any benefit to the game to seeing a punter or kicker laid out by a brutal hit.
Is there benefit to other special teamers getting laid out by brutal hits? I'm not calling for unnecessary roughness towards kickers but if they want to try and tackle somebody they shouldn't get any more protection than any other player would get.
Though, if I had my way, I'd get rid of kicking altogether in football.
posted by tron7 at 04:06 PM on January 14
Yeah, like those wussy receivers who are in the air, or those candy-ass runners who have already been stopped -- or, the worst of them all, that wimpy non-football-playing "kickoff or punt returner attempting to field a kick in the air."
Those are all defenseless positions. A kicker during the return: not a defenseless position. What about being a kicker makes him more defenseless than any other special teamer trying to cover a kick?
Wimpy, candy-ass, wussy... I mean, the sarcasm is great but I don't see how that's my side of the argument labeling them as such. The rulebook essentially implies that they're not football players if they're always considered defenseless.
posted by tron7 at 03:07 PM on January 14
It isn't a new ruling. In a rule against hitting players in a defenseless posture, the NFL rulebook includes in the definition "a kicker/punter during the kick or during the return." I don't see anything ridiculous about the rule.
Then shouldn't they just leave the field directly after kicking? Once a kicker/punter is through his kicking motion he's not defenseless, he can defend himself by staying away from the action if he doesn't want to play football.
posted by tron7 at 02:16 PM on January 14
What in the actual fuck was Colston doing there?
Hit the wrong button on the controller.
posted by tron7 at 07:47 PM on January 11
Awww, man. We were cheated out of a Hail Mary attempt.
Edit: 'We' being viewers. Love Hail Marys.
posted by tron7 at 07:46 PM on January 11
Bob Costas Rips Olympic Snowboarding Slopestyle, Calls It Jackass Stuff'
Why slopestyle, just because it's new to the Olympics? I don't see how he's cool with halfpipe but slopestyle is Jackass stuff. Anyway, I'm far more interested in slopestyle competitions than halfpipe.
posted by tron7 at 02:47 PM on January 09
Btw, congrats to tron7 and owlhouse for finishing with a 135-115 record against the spread. tron7 wins via tie breakers.
Woo! Back-to-back pick-em champion!
I've heard the break even line for betting NFL games is right around 52.5% which means only 4 spofites, out of the 20 or so that were active the entire year, would have made any money if they bet all the games.
posted by tron7 at 03:47 PM on January 07
The Kings are 4-6 with Gay in the lineup, which is actually an improvement percentage wise for them, but he's also shooting an unsustainable 48% from the field. There will be regression.
True shooting .558 which is higher than any of his single season marks. Though, he is rebounding at a career low rate and turning the ball over at a career high rate since the trade so regression will both hurt and help him.
Really, I don't think he's that bad of a player, just the most overpaid and overrated. Here are some of the guys on his similarity scores on basketball reference: Thad Young, Jared Dudley, Marvin Williams. If he was held in the same regard as those guys I probably would never talk about the guy.
posted by tron7 at 12:08 PM on January 02
The Raptors are 9-3 over their last 12 with wins over the Thunder and the Pacers. The best part about trading for Rudy Gay is how good you get when you eventually trade him away.
posted by tron7 at 10:10 AM on January 02
Copyright © 2014 SportsFilterAll posts and comments are © their original authors.